Alternatives to Melatonin

14 options are rated for the same goals as Melatonin (Sleep). They are ranked by how well each one scores on the goals Melatonin is used for.

Updated .

See everything about Melatonin

Quick picks

Three ways to choose, depending on what matters to you.

Closest alternatives

Each score is that option's own evidence for that goal. Higher is stronger.

  1. Scores higher than Melatonin for Sleep.

    Safety
    Well tolerated
    Effort
    Moderate
    Cost
    Free
    Starts working
    ~7 days
  2. Scores higher than Melatonin for Sleep.

    Safety
    Well tolerated
    Effort
    Easy
    Cost
    Free
    Starts working
    Same day
  3. Scores higher than Melatonin for Sleep.

    Safety
    Use with care
    Effort
    Very easy
    Cost
    Low cost
    Starts working
    ~2 weeks
  4. Safety
    Well tolerated
    Effort
    Easy
    Cost
    Free
    Starts working
    ~4 weeks
  5. Safety
    Well tolerated
    Effort
    Very easy
    Cost
    Free
    Starts working
    ~3 days
  6. Safety
    Well tolerated
    Effort
    Very easy
    Cost
    Paid
    Starts working
    ~2 weeks
  7. Safety
    Well tolerated
    Effort
    Easy
    Cost
    Free
    Starts working
    Same day
  8. Safety
    Well tolerated
    Effort
    Very easy
    Cost
    Low cost
  9. Safety
    Well tolerated
    Effort
    Very easy
    Cost
    Free
    Starts working
    Same day
  10. Safety
    Well tolerated
    Effort
    Very easy
    Cost
    Low cost
    Starts working
    ~7 days
  11. Safety
    Well tolerated
    Effort
    Moderate
    Cost
    Free
    Starts working
    Same day
  12. Safety
    Use with care
    Effort
    Very easy
    Cost
    Low cost
    Starts working
    ~2 weeks

Best alternative for each goal

Melatonin against the strongest options for every goal it is rated for.

How to read XP

Each score is for one option and one goal, not a general rating.

XP combines how reliable the research is with how much difference it usually makes. Higher means stronger evidence for that supplement and that goal.

Limited<15 XPModest15–27 XPModerate28–44 XPReliable45–69 XPHigh70+ XP

Compare more than one goal at once.

Pick what you want to improve and see which supplements and protocols have the strongest research behind them.

Open the finder