Magnesium vs Probiotics

Both are rated for 4 of the same goals. Magnesium and Probiotics are level: each scores higher on 0 of the 4 goals they share, and 4 are about the same. Scores are for one goal at a time, so the answer depends on what you want to improve.

Updated . Scores combine the size of the effect in published research with how strong that research is.

Which one fits you

Each line is read straight from the two pages, and only shown where the two differ.

  • Starts working soonerMagnesiumFor Mood, Magnesium shows a first effect in about 2 weeks, Probiotics in about 4 weeks.

Goal by goal

The longer bar has the stronger evidence for that goal. Within 5 points counts as about the same.

Mood & Depression

About the same

Magnesium

Modest evidenceHuman trialsFirst effect about 2 weeksFull effect about 6 weeks3 studies cited

May ease mild to moderate depression, mostly from small trials.

Sources: Study 1, Study 2, Study 3

Probiotics

Modest evidenceHuman trialsFirst effect about 4 weeksFull effect about 8 weeks2 studies cited

Small improvement in low mood in healthy adults across 20 trials; effects vary by strain.

Sources: Study 1, Study 2

Blood Sugar Control

About the same

Magnesium

Modest evidenceHuman trialsFirst effect about 4 weeksFull effect about 3 months6 studies cited

Improves fasting blood sugar and insulin sensitivity in people with diabetes or at high risk.

Sources: Study 1, Study 2, Study 3, Study 4

Probiotics

Modest evidenceHuman trialsFirst effect about 8 weeksFull effect about 3 months4 studies cited

Lowers fasting blood sugar slightly in people with diabetes.

Sources: Study 1, Study 2, Study 3, Study 4

Stress & Anxiety

About the same

Magnesium

Limited evidenceHuman trialsFirst effect about 2 weeksFull effect about 6 weeks2 studies cited

May modestly ease anxiety in people already prone to it, but trials are small and inconsistent, and the best single review found no effect on postpartum anxiety specifically.

Sources: Study 1, Study 2

Probiotics

Limited evidenceHuman trialsFirst effect about 4 weeksFull effect about 8 weeks2 studies cited

Small and inconsistent effects on stress and anxiety.

Sources: Study 1, Study 2

Dose, effort and cost

What each one asks of you.

Magnesium

Usual dose
200–400 mg per day. 200–400 mg/day (tolerable upper intake level for supplemental magnesium is 350 mg/day)
Effort
Very easy
Cost
Low cost

Probiotics

Usual dose
1–10 billion CFU per day. 1 billion to 20 billion CFU/day (specific therapeutic formulas reach 50–100+ billion CFU)
Effort
Very easy
Cost
Low cost

Safety

Plain-language notes for each. Not medical advice.

Magnesium

Well tolerated Mild effects, if any.

  • Loose stools. Very common above 350 mg, especially oxide or citrate.

Check with a doctor first if you have kidney disease or take certain antibiotics.

Probiotics

Well tolerated Mild effects, if any.

  • Gas and bloating. Common in the first 1–2 weeks. Usually passes.

Check with a doctor first if your immune system is weakened or you're seriously ill.

Rated for one but not the other

Goals where only one of them has reliable evidence.

Who talks about them

Public figures who say they use or recommend each. Scores rate the evidence, not the person.

Common questions

Is Magnesium or Probiotics better for Mood?

They score about the same for Mood & Depression: Magnesium 21/100 (Modest), Probiotics 23/100 (Modest). Magnesium and Probiotics are level: each scores higher on 0 of the 4 goals they share, and 4 are about the same.

How long do Magnesium and Probiotics take to work?

For Mood & Depression, Magnesium shows a first effect in about 2 weeks and reaches its full effect in about 6 weeks. Probiotics shows a first effect in about 4 weeks and reaches its full effect in about 8 weeks.

Which is safer, Magnesium or Probiotics?

Magnesium is rated "Well tolerated" and Probiotics "Well tolerated". Magnesium: Loose stools. Probiotics: Gas and bloating. Safety depends on your health and any medication you take, so check with a doctor or pharmacist if in doubt.

Can you take Magnesium and Probiotics together?

We do not list them as a pairing. Read the dose and safety notes on each page first, and ask a doctor or pharmacist if you take medication.

What is the usual dose of Magnesium and Probiotics?

Magnesium: 200–400 mg per day. 200–400 mg/day (tolerable upper intake level for supplemental magnesium is 350 mg/day). Probiotics: 1–10 billion CFU per day. 1 billion to 20 billion CFU/day (specific therapeutic formulas reach 50–100+ billion CFU).

Evidence base: Magnesium 28 studies, Probiotics 9. Every score is for one goal, built from the size of the effect and the strength of the research. How scoring works.

How to read XP

Educational information, not medical advice.

XP combines how reliable the research is with how much difference it usually makes. Higher means stronger evidence for that supplement and that goal.

Limited<15 XPModest15–27 XPModerate28–44 XPReliable45–69 XPHigh70+ XP

See the full picture for each one.

Every goal, dose, safety note and the research behind the scores.

MagnesiumProbioticsAlternatives to MagnesiumAlternatives to Probiotics